The Best Bike Saddle: Top Picks

Best Bike Saddle

As Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying Purchases – at no extra cost to you Learn More

When you’re riding your bicycle especially during competitions or long distances you always want to be comfortable. The best bike saddle could make a massive difference between an extremely unpleasant ride and an enjoyable one.

To get the most of your ride, you need the right saddle. A bike saddle is one of the essential parts of a bicycle with frame, tire, pedals, and chains and is where the friction and weight are held during your rides.

However, selecting the wrong model may lead to discomfort, and worst affect your performance.

Different riding environment has various demands, hence just because one works for a certain rider does not mean it is going to work for you as well. So for you to get the bike seat that suits your needs, there are some critical factors that you need to consider.

To help you, we will provide and explain all the important things that you need to know when it comes to choosing the right one and then offer you a collection of the best bike saddles that are currently available on the market.

​Nevertheless, here’s an overview of our top five overall picks.

IMAGE PRODUCT RAting Price 
Best Bike SaddleSelle ITALIA MAX SLR Gel Flow Vanox Selle ITALIA MAX SLR Gel Flow Vanox
9.5
Best Women Bike SaddleSelle Italia Diva Gel Bicycle Saddle Serfas RX Bicycle Saddle
9.5
Best Big Size Bike SaddleBikeroo Oversized Comfort Bike Seat Bikeroo Oversized Comfort Bike Seat
9
OUR BUDGET PICKBikeroo Most Comfortable Bike Seat Bikeroo Most Comfortable Bike Seat For Men
9

Reviews of the Best Bike Saddles

Selle ITALIA MAX SLR Gel Flow Vanox – Best Bike Saddle

selle ITALIA Max SLR Gel Flow Vanox
146 Reviews
selle ITALIA Max SLR Gel Flow Vanox
  • GEL COMFORT - The special Superflow anatomic cut-out combined with a gel layer provides excellent comfort to soft tissue areas by offering greater flexibility at the front of the road bike saddle. Combined with a thin layer of silicone gel it absorbs road vibrations
  • DURABLE & LIGHTWEIGHT - Our saddles have a microfiber cover material, Fibra-Tek, that guarantees a strong and durable lifetime at a very low weight
  • EXTRA PADDING - Increased padding in this road saddle ensures durable riding positioning for long distances and provides the rider protection against skin inflammation
  • TITANIUM RAILS - The Max SLR Superflow saddle is made with round 7 mm Ti316 rails which increase resistance and durability by up to 25% and reduce weight by 15% when compared with traditional rails
  • OUR GUARANTEE - Selle Italia guarantees its products against material and/or manufacturing defects for twenty-four (24) months from the date of purchase

The Max SLR Gel Flow Vanox is one of the most comfortable bicycle seats from Selle ITALIA. This offers supreme performance and comfort.

The Selle ITALIA, on the other hand, utilized an innovative technology in creating this item to maximize rider comfort for the optimum riding experience off and on the road.

Either way, it’s one of the most iconic and stylish seats of the Selle ITALIA’s Max Range.

Construction

The 10 percent carbon construction of this cycle saddle is stiff enough and can offer great support.

Its Vanadium-titanium alloy rails are lighter and provide sturdy as well as strong performance.

Furthermore, its Loricas manmade leather cover provides high levels of scratch resistance.

Padding

The self-molding padding of Max SLR Gel Flow Saddle provides every rider a custom fit. In addition to that, the padding relieves pressure which makes your ride more comfortable.

Weight and Dimensions

​The bike seat weighs 250 grams and has a total dimension of 145” (W) by 275” (L). Even though it’s not the lightest saddle, this can offer you the comfort and durability that you’re looking for a bike saddle.

Things We Liked

  • ​Comfortable
  • ​Its gel padding works well
  • ​Nice Shape
  • ​Relieves pressure
  • ​Great value for the money

Things We Didn’t Like

  • ​It’s a bit heavy
  • ​Need some breaking in

Customer Reviews

Customers have found this bike saddle from Selle ITALIA a great buy since it offers comfort and excellent performance. They also liked the high-quality padding and leather of this product.  

However, some customers said that this bicycle seat is heavy at the same time.

Final Impression

Overall, the Selle Italia Max SLR Gel Flow is comfortable and well-made perch. Not only that, it is ideal for longer stints as well as on and off road ride.

​Also, we’re recommending this product to professional cyclists.

Serfas RX Bicycle Saddle Best Bike Saddle for Women

Serfas Rx Comfort Women's Bicycle Saddle
268 Reviews
Serfas Rx Comfort Women's Bicycle Saddle
  • 90-Day Comfort Guarantee on all saddles
  • Patented I.C.S. Infinite Comfort System
  • RX & Deep Groove designs
  • Dual Density base technology
  • Patented Dual Density Base

Finally, Serfas has introduced a bike saddle that is specifically designed for women. The RX bike saddle features a shape which is ideal for the women’s posture and anatomy.

Aside from that, it is a high performance as well as a comfortable bike seat.

Construction

This Saddle is built with comfy Microfiber.

It also has an dual density that absorbs vibrations even bumps over uneven terrains. On the other hand, its Vanox rails can offer lightweight strength.

Moreover, its cut out area relive pressure in soft tissues and improve comfort.

Padding

This product is equipped with breathable padding. The RX bike saddle has differentiated-thickness padding.

Moreover, it has full-grain leather covering that adheres to your body for more support.

Comfort

​This all-around bike seat offers great comfort for both long and short rides making it a nice option for all but serious racers.

Things We Liked

  • ​Comfortable
  • ​Perfect for an all-day ride
  • ​Ideal for women
  • ​Versatile
  • ​Lightweight

Things We Didn’t Like

  • ​Not low profile
  • ​Voluminous

Customer Reviews

Lots of customers are writing good feedback about this saddle for women because it is very comfortable. As a matter of fact, they even revealed that they don’t feel any pain while and after cycling.

Either way, the majority of customers loved how Serfas made this bike saddle.

Final Impression

A superior and high-quality bike saddle from Serfas that offers impressive comfort to all riders.

​Also, it’s a good option especially if you love the substantial amount of padding for your back end.

Bikeroo Oversized Comfort Bike Seat – Best Big Size Bike Paddle

Sale
Bikeroo Oversized Comfort Bike Seat
18,144 Reviews
Bikeroo Oversized Comfort Bike Seat
  • These bike seats are built with extra padding and steel spring suspension that can help spare you from discomfort, all while distributing the pressure evenly. This is a great bike seat replacement for an outdoor bike!
  • Tested by more than 25,000 cycling enthusiasts, this bike saddle is a perfect fit for those seeking extra comfortable outdoor bike seats.
  • This deal comes with perks! You'll get a waterproof bicycle cover, easy-to-use tools to mount, a universal bicycle seat adapter, mounting instructions, and an ebook filled with additional info as well!
  • This wide bike seat is nimble, ergonomic and has universal construction to make it compatible with all standard bikes!
  • The universal mount will fit your ride whether it is a cruiser, mountain, road city, fixed gear, or touring bike. The steel springs and standard rails mount system make this padded bike seat stand out against the rest.

This wide Bikeroo bike saddle suits both males and females. Moreover, it has an extra suspension spring which will take the bumps effortlessly.

The Bikeroo Oversized Comfort Bike Seat is ideal for both indoor and outdoor purposes. Also, it’s made from premium quality faux leather. With that said, Bikeroo certainly doesn’t fail to impress millions of individuals with its durability.

Nevertheless, like most Bikeroo bike seats, this model is also a great option for those who want to upgrade their bicycle seats.

Comfort

Because of its dual spring suspension and thick padding, it is considered as one of the softest and most comfortable Bikeroo bike saddles since it makes you feel amazing and improves comfort on your bicycle.

Easy to Install

This best bike saddle improves bike quality, and it is best to utilize in on road bikes, fixed gear, touring, mountain bikes, and cruiser.

One of the best things about this item is that it’s easy to install. As a matter of fact, it comes with an adaptor and regular rails mount system.

Versatile

​The bike saddle is ideal for those who are looking for a versatile bike saddle. As what we said a while ago, it can be used for both indoor and outdoor purposes, thanks to its wide design and soft padding.

Things We Liked

  • ​Easy to install
  • ​Comfortable
  • ​Great for outdoor and indoor bicycles
  • ​Wide padding
  • ​Versatile
  • ​One year warranty

Things We Didn’t Like

  • ​The seat may slide off
  • ​Wide padding but not lenient

Customer Reviews

It’s good to hear the lots of customers can install this saddle in just a few minutes. Loads of customers have changed their seat with this item from Bikeroo.

They have also found out that it is very affordable. Its dual spring suspension, thick padding, and wideness are the most noticeable features of this saddle.

Final Impression

If you’re looking for full and stiff bicycle saddle that has thick padding, then this one is for you.  However, if you’re looking for a soft one, unfortunately, this is not for you.

​Either way, its dual spring suspension performs very well when it comes to absorbing vibrations.

Bikeroo Most Comfortable Bike Seat for Men – Best Bike Saddle for Men

Sale
Bikeroo Most Comfortable Bike Seat
4,391 Reviews
Bikeroo Most Comfortable Bike Seat
  • CUSTOM COMFORT: This comfortable bike saddle for men is designed to support your sit bones while touring or riding a mountain bike. Tested by over 12,000 cyclists, this ergonomic and prostate friendly bicycle seat will help you go the distance.
  • ERGONOMIC DESIGN: The narrow nose allows for more free range of motion to reduce chafing. Center cutout distributes weight evenly to provide relief to the soft tissue of the genitals while enhancing upright posture. Vent hole allows for more breathability to reduce sweating and soggy apparel.
  • NO BUTT NUMBNESS: The premium memory foam padding and responsive suspension of this comfortable bike seat stop your rear from falling asleep. Adjustable bike mount to accommodate any angle you prefer. Ride for longer without soreness or hot spots!
  • UNIVERSAL MOUNT: Replace any stock bike saddle with these comfy bike seats for men. The universal mount allows for easy installation on any standard bike post. Includes mounting tools and rainproof bike seat cover.
  • CUSTOMER SUPPORT: Our team is always ready to get into gear and help with any questions or concerns you might have about your bicycle saddle. We are available to make sure that your customer journey rides like a dream.

This is perhaps the most comfortable bicycle seat made by Bikeroo. It is designed for guys’ anatomy.

Bikeroo created this bike saddle so that men will no longer feel pressure on their prostate when biking. Moreover, the manufacturer also assures you that this item has all the features that you’re looking for a high-quality bike saddle.

Versatile

Whether it is installed as a road bike seat or mountain bike saddle this comfortable equipment will surely make your riding experience much better.

Moreover, because of its usual rails system and adaptor, it perfectly suits other kinds of bikes such as indoor cycling and fixed gear.   

Appearance

Because of its smooth leather finish and a great look, your bicycle will look amazing with this bike saddle from Bikeroo that nice sports curves and simple design.

Either way, it also has a great feel.

Comfort

The base of this bike saddle is well padded giving long period riding desire for males and bones which apply pressure to the seat directly.

​On the other hand, this Bikeroo bike saddle is functional for any road bike for performance as well as comfort.

Things We Liked

  • ​Incredible inexpensive
  • ​Easy to install
  • ​Versatile and durable
  • ​Perfect for men who are suffering from scrotal pain
  • ​Comfortable
  • ​Features a shockwave absorbing technology

Things We Didn’t Like

  • ​It’s specifically designed for men
  • ​The reduced surfaces minimize comfort

Customer Reviews 

Myriads of customers have approved and tested the effectiveness of this bike saddle.

According to some users, this item allows them to paddle for a couple of hours and distances without experiencing body pain or strain.

Either way, this bicycle saddle from Bikeroo is top-notch when it comes to comfort, said, customers.

Final Impression

Without a doubt, this saddle is a comfortable option. Coupled with soft cushion and additional padding this product lessens the effect as well as the strength of shock to inconsequential to negligible levels.

Its diverse suitability is also an additional benefit. Nevertheless, Bikeroo Most Comfortable Seat is an item that is something worth getting.

How to Choose the Best Bike Saddle

Listed below are some of the essential things that you need to consider before making a purchase. Trust us, if consider these things you will end up with an option that will suit you the most.

  • Size and Shape

If you’re a kind of rider who prefer to sit in an upright position, you will need to look for a bike saddle that is wider and curved.

On the other hand, if you’re riding in a low position, then a flatter and a narrower bike saddle are perfect for you.

To identify the size, you’re advised to measure the space between the two depressions created by your sit bones. After which add 25mm to 30mm to determine the right saddle width.

More: Check our guide to the most comfortable bike seat for overweight

  • Materials

The materials used in making the bike saddle will play an important role when it comes to comfort.

Most comfortable bike saddles are created using either padded plastic or leather materials. Even so, a seat that is made with carbon fiber is also a great option.

Carbon fibers are light in weight, strong, and most importantly offer a good level of comfort.

However, some models don’t have shell burst. Instead, they depend on the dense leather stretched to the front and rear side of the rails. But such models aren’t worth considering if comfort is your main concern.

  • Padding

Some bike saddle manufacturers usually use silicone, gel, plastic foam, and other soft synthetics to absorb impact.

​This feature makes a saddle more comfortable. Nevertheless, if you’re buying a saddle make sure to go for padding that is not too soft and too hard.

More: Terry Corta Saddle Review: Worth A Buy?

  • Rails

Rails attach the seat to the bicycle itself. Usually, they are secured to the seat support and riders can adjust it.

Undeniably, it an essential thing to consider when you’re replacing or buying a new bike saddle.

Look for rails that are made of sturdy materials, because it affects the saddle’s comfort.

  • Cover

Most bike saddles are covered with classic leather or synthetic fiber. If you want to have a seat that can withstand any element that you may encounter during your rides make sure to opt for a model that comes with a durable cover.

However, if you see reinforces, or stitching panels make that they will cause discomfort or chafe. 

More: Brooks England B17 Steel Saddle Review: All you need to know

  • Weight

If you are fascinated in road riding, consider the saddle’s weight is necessary. If you are planning to race you can go for a light option.

However, some users tend to invest in heavier models and sacrifice the weight to add more comfort for their rear end.

  • Price 

You don’t have to spend thousands of dollars to get a high-quality saddle. Vintage-looking that are made using leather and extremely lightweight seats are costlier.

Keep in mind that not all expensive models offer superior comfort. Thus you need to be careful when choosing.

  • Cut out 

Some bike saddles have a hole in the middle. This feature lessens pressure on sensitive parts as well as improve blood flow to avoid numbness.

​Thus, if you’re experiencing numbness, then look for a bike saddle that possesses this feature.

More: Terry Butterfly Century Saddle Review

1. What Is The Advantage of Wide Bike Saddles?

​Wider bike saddles offer more comfort, especially for wider and heavier riders. Not only that they also allow additional positions.

2. Do more cushioning means more comfortable rides?

​Not necessarily, because excessive cushion may lessen the amount of support you will receive.

3. What Makes A Decent/Good Bike Saddle?

​A decent bike saddle will support your sit bones, not your bum. The part where the bike saddle meets the sit bones is important. And that is one of the main reasons why the majority of manufacturers provide their bike saddles in changing widths to accommodate people’s anatomy.

Final Words

Choosing the best bike saddle for your bicycle is very crucial. It offers you comfort while riding and speed while racing.

However, if you’re not sure which of the products mentioned above is worth considering, you may want to invest in Selle Italia Max SLR Gel Flow Vanox.

For us, this is the real winner because it is loaded with impressive features that are not present in other models. Aside from that, it is also top-notch when it comes overall performance and providing comfort.

​Furthermore, it looks very stylish and uses innovative technology. Most importantly it’s an excellent value for your money.